How to revise a novel in four weeks: sentences go last
How to revise a novel in four weeks of December: read and take notes, fix the structure, check continuity against a story bible, and edit sentences last.
Luis Morales19 min read

This is how to revise a novel in four weeks, from 1 to 28 December 2026: read the whole draft and take notes in week 1, fix structure in week 2, check continuity against a story bible in week 3, and edit lines and style in week 4. One layer gets one week. The order is the method.
Two older revisions show the order on the page. Cervantes answered a structural complaint about Don Quixote by changing what he inserted, and Mary Shelley changed one family fact in Frankenstein and then repaired a later word that depended on it.
How to revise a novel in four weeks: the plan at a glance
| Week | Dates | Layer | You change | You do not touch yet |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 to 7 December | Read-through and notes | Nothing in the text (typos only) | Scenes, sentences |
| 2 | 8 to 14 December | Structure | Scene order, cuts, missing scenes, the opening | Sentences |
| 3 | 15 to 21 December | Continuity against a bible | Names, dates, facts that contradict the bible | Style |
| 4 | 22 to 28 December | Line and style | Sentences, rhythm, repetition | Plot |
This table is the novel revision plan. Each section below explains one row and ends with a checklist you can work from without rereading the whole post.
29 to 31 December are spare days on purpose. 24 and 25 December fall on Thursday and Friday of week 4, so week 4 has five working days if you take those two days off, and it is the lightest week.
The hard rule sits under the whole table: do not rewrite a single sentence before week 4, even an ugly one. Fix a typo if you see it, and leave everything else. A sentence polished in week 1 can be cut in week 2. A sentence polished in week 2 can change again in week 3, when a name or a date changes. Structure changes leave continuity debts, and continuity fixes change sentences, so sentence work goes last.
Before 1 December: rest, and save the first draft untouched
Zadie Smith gives rule 5 in The Guardian's "Ten rules for writing fiction", published on 20 February 2010 in part two: "Leave a decent space of time between writing something and editing it." That rule is a problem for a December plan. If your draft ends on 30 November, 1 December is no space at all.
You still remember what you meant to put on the page, and memory fills the gaps for you. So move the dates. Start the plan on 15 December and finish on 11 January, or treat the first week as rest. The four weeks keep their order, and the work gets the distance Smith describes.
Our earlier post on the NaNoWriMo month covers the days right after a 50,000-word November. This post starts where that one ends: with a complete draft and a saved copy.
Before any reading starts, save a named snapshot of the untouched first draft. On the Free plan, Journzy versions can save up to 500 snapshots per book, with a name of up to 120 characters and a note of up to 1,000 characters. Name it something you will understand in February, such as "Draft 1, untouched, 30 November", and put what you know is missing in the note.
Cuts feel safer when the cut text still exists somewhere with a date on it. Before a restore, Journzy saves the current text in a snapshot, and you can compare versions. Save before the opinions start: the untouched copy shows what you actually wrote in November.
Week 1 (1 to 7 December): read the whole draft and take notes
Week 1 asks for one complete read, from the first page to the last, with notes beside the text and no repairs inside it. A problem in chapter 4 can be a setup for chapter 19. You cannot know which until you have read chapter 19.

Freshness is not available, and the plan admits it. Margaret Atwood states the limit in rule 8 in part one of the same Guardian series:
"You can never read your own book with the innocent anticipation that comes with that first delicious page of a new book, because you wrote the thing. You've been backstage. You've seen how the rabbits were smuggled into the hat."
Zadie Smith, in rule 2, gives the standard for the week: "When an adult, try to read your own work as a stranger would read it, or even better, as an enemy would." A stranger has no access to your intention. Mark what the page does, and write down separately what you hoped it would do.
Write the doubts as questions. "Does chapter 9 give a reason for her return, or do I only know the reason from the outline?" is a usable note. "Chapter 9 is fine" is a memory wearing a judge's coat.
Hold back new pages until the end. Holly Lisle gives the reason: "Don't do this before you've done one complete read-through, because as you get to the end of the book, you'll find places where you jumped to conclusions that you'll need to support earlier in the book." If you can, read in a different format (print, another file type, another screen). It will not give you Atwood's innocent first page, but it can slow your eyes down on paragraphs your hands remember typing.
Keep four lists as you read:
- A scene list, one line per scene: who has the point of view, what changes, which thread opens or closes. "Marta, learns the letter was forged, opens the debt thread" tells you more in week 2 than "Marta at the house, sad".
- A problem list, each problem with its chapter: "the trip takes one evening here and three days later", "the brother's age changes", "this reveal arrives before the clue". Do not solve them in the margin.
- A fact list: every name, date and age as you meet it, with its chapter and every form of each name. Do not correct anything yet. In week 1 you cannot tell a nickname from an accident.
- A skim list: the scenes you read fast. Week 2 starts there.
Lisle goes further than this plan: the "little mistakes" she corrects in the margins while she reads include awkward sentences and vague bits of dialogue. This plan is stricter: fix the typo, leave the flat sentence flat. At the end of the week the text is almost unchanged. That is fine. This is the only week that sees the book entire.
Checklist:
- Read every chapter once, from the start to the end
- Write one line per scene in the scene list, with point of view, change and thread
- Note each problem with the chapter where it appears
- Write down every name, date and age as you meet it
- Mark the scenes you skimmed while reading
- Write no new scenes during the read
- Save a snapshot at the end of the week
Week 2 (8 to 14 December): fix the structure
Week 2 is the only week licensed to move the furniture. Scene order, cuts, missing scenes and the opening belong here. Sentences stay out of reach.

Worked example: the novella Cervantes put in the wrong place
Part I of Don Quixote spends chapters XXXIII to XXXV on an inserted novella, "The Ill-advised Curiosity" (in Spanish, El curioso impertinente). It has its own cast. The main story waits while it runs.
In Part II, chapter 3, a character reports what readers said about Part I. The passage uses the Ormsby translation on Project Gutenberg:
"One of the faults they find with this history," said the bachelor, "is that its author inserted in it a novel called 'The Ill-advised Curiosity;' not that it is bad or ill-told, but that it is out of place and has nothing to do with the history of his worship Señor Don Quixote."
Read that complaint slowly. The readers accept the telling. Their charge is the placement: the novella is "out of place" and has "nothing to do with the history" around it. Better sentences cannot answer a note like that, because the sentences were never accused.
In Part II, chapter 44, the narrator gives the author's answer. He had used novels "like 'The Ill-advised Curiosity,' and 'The Captive Captain,' which stand, as it were, apart from the story", and he thought that many readers "would take none in the novels, and pass them over hastily or impatiently". Then the method changes: "Therefore in this Second Part he thought it best not to insert novels, either separate or interwoven, but only episodes, something like them, arising out of the circumstances the facts present; and even these sparingly, and with no more words than suffice to make them plain". He asks for credit "not alone for what he writes, but for what he has refrained from writing."
Cervantes does not defend the novellas by praising their prose. He changes the rule for what enters the book. That is a structural answer to a structural note.
Your week 1 notes will hold the modern form of the same complaint: this chapter feels long, this backstory arrives too early, this subplot vanishes. Each asks for a decision about order or presence, and none asks for a better adjective. Elmore Leonard's rule 10 in part one of the Guardian series sits next to it: "Try to leave out the part that readers tend to skip." Your skim list already names those parts.
The structure questions
What changes in each scene? Open the scene list. A scene can change a decision, a relationship, a danger or what the reader knows. Two scenes in a row that change the same thing, or a long scene that changes nothing until its last paragraph, get a decision: cut, merge, move, or rewrite at the level of action.
Where does the novel actually start? Hilary Mantel, rule 6 in part two: "First paragraphs can often be struck out." Sarah Waters, rule 2 in the same part, describes reaching the beginning of, say, chapter two in a manuscript, her own included, and thinking "This is where the novel should actually start." Test your book from the first scene where something changes, and treat the pages before it as material to raid.
Which threads open and never close? Follow each one in the scene list from its first line to its last mention. A thread can close with an answer, a failure or a deliberate refusal. A thread that stops because the draft moved on is a debt, and December is a good month to pay it on paper.
Where did the plot go wrong? Margaret Atwood, rule 9 in part one: "If you're lost in the plot or blocked, retrace your steps to where you went wrong. Then take the other road." You are not blocked now, but retrace anyway. Find the first scene where the ending stopped following from the action. A repair at that point costs less than repairs spread over every later chapter.
Cut by archiving. A cut scene can hold a fact or a voice you need later. In Journzy, archived chapters can be recovered for 30 days from the recovery bin, so archive with a clear name and write the reason for the cut in your problem list.
A scene list on paper does the week 2 job for free, slower; its limit is search in a long book. On the Author plan, at US$19/month or US$180/year, plus tax, the developmental diagnosis reads structure, pacing, tension arcs, dialogue and theme, and gives a revision plan ordered by impact. Each finding cites the passage behind it, and it never rewrites.
Either way, end the week with a written record: which chapters moved, which scenes are new, which events now happen earlier or later. Week 3 checks the book against it. A structural change you cannot list is a continuity problem you have chosen to meet by surprise.
Checklist:
- Decide each skimmed scene: cut, move, shorten, or keep with a stated reason
- Test the opening from the first scene where something changes
- Follow every opened thread to its close or mark it as a debt
- Write the missing scenes the structure needs, at scene level first
- Archive cuts instead of deleting them
- List every change of order, cast and timing for week 3
- Save a snapshot at the end of the week
Week 3 (15 to 21 December): check continuity against a story bible
Week 3 checks the facts of the book against a written record of those facts: names, ages, dates, travel times, objects, and who knows what and when. Style waits one more week.

Worked example: Mary Shelley changed a cousin into an orphan
In the 1831 edition of Frankenstein, on Project Gutenberg, Shelley's introduction is dated London, 15 October 1831. She describes her revision in modest terms:
"I will add but one word as to the alterations I have made. They are principally those of style. I have changed no portion of the story, nor introduced any new ideas or circumstances. I have mended the language where it was so bald as to interfere with the interest of the narrative; and these changes occur almost exclusively in the beginning of the first volume."
Chapter I shows a bigger change. In the 1818 text, also on Project Gutenberg, Victor's father "had a sister", and he is asked "to take charge of the infant Elizabeth, the only child of his deceased sister". Elizabeth is Victor's cousin by blood.
In 1831, Elizabeth "was not her child, but the daughter of a Milanese nobleman. Her mother was a German, and had died on giving her birth." The cousin has become an orphan with no blood tie to Victor, and the reason she enters the Frankenstein house has changed with her parents.
The repair is one sentence, added in 1831 to chapter I: "We called each other familiarly by the name of cousin." It is not in the 1818 text. Its work shows in chapter VI, where Elizabeth's letter opens "My dearest Cousin," (in 1818 the same letter opened "MY DEAR COUSIN,"). Without the new sentence, that word would rest on a family tie the revised chapter I had removed.
Our reading stays on the page and makes no claim about Shelley's reasons. A change to one fact in the opening chapter reaches every later page that depends on it, and she paid the debt at the exact place where a later page used the old fact.
Week 2 does the same thing to your draft, at a smaller scale. An age stated in a moved chapter can collide with a birthday in its new neighbour. An object destroyed in chapter 8 can sit intact in chapter 12, because chapter 12 was written before you decided on the destruction. From the reader's chair this looks like carelessness. From the writer's chair it is the normal residue of structural work, and it needs a pass of its own.
Build the bible from the draft, not from memory
Memory holds the book you intended. The bible must hold the book you wrote. Start from the week 1 fact list and write down every fact as the draft states it, with its chapter: names and every alias, ages, dates and travel times, who knows what and when, the objects the plot depends on. A fact without a chapter is an opinion.
Write facts that change over time as changes. A character can believe a lie in chapter 4 and learn the truth in chapter 15; both entries belong in the bible, each with its chapter. A scene checked against one static fact will raise false alarms and miss real breaks.
Then read the draft against the bible one category at a time. Follow every mention of a name. Follow the dates in order and the travel times between them. Category reads are dry, and the dryness is the point: a story read hides a wrong date inside a good scene, and a date read has nowhere to hide.
The manuscript continuity checklist has the detailed method, in eight categories.
In Journzy, the story bible holds character sheets, aliases, relationships and facts that change over time. On the Author plan, the continuity check compares each scene with the bible, and each flag cites the bible line that proves it. You fix the text or mark the point intentional.
The limit: a checker only knows what the bible holds. A wrong bible line produces confident flags against right text. And no check writes Shelley's sentence. A check can show you that chapter I and chapter VI collide; "We called each other familiarly by the name of cousin" is a decision only the author makes.
Mark intentional breaks as intentional while the reason is fresh. A gap you chose in December can look like an error to you in March.
Checklist:
- Build the bible from the draft, with a chapter for every fact
- Enter names, aliases, ages, dates, travel times, knowledge and objects
- Read category by category against the bible
- Check every scene moved, cut or added in week 2 for stranded facts
- Fix each collision in the text or mark it intentional with a reason
- Update the bible to match the corrected draft
- Save a snapshot at the end of the week
Week 4 (22 to 28 December): line and style
Week 4 finally reaches the sentence. Plot stays closed: a plot idea that arrives now goes into a note for the next draft, because a plot change would reopen weeks 2 and 3 in the last week of the plan.
Diana Athill gives the method in rule 1 in part one: "Read it aloud to yourself because that's the only way to be sure the rhythms of the sentences are OK". The ear catches what the eye forgives. A sentence can pass a silent read on its meaning and still stumble when spoken.
Helen Dunmore, rule 2 in the same part, adds a second use for the stumble: "Listen to what you have written. A dud rhythm in a passage of dialogue may show that you don't yet understand the characters well enough to write in their voices." Some flat dialogue needs a cut. Some needs a scene decision in the next draft, so mark it and move on.
Shelley's account of her own line work fits this week: she "mended the language where it was so bald as to interfere with the interest of the narrative". Mending is the right scale. A mended sentence keeps its fact, its speaker and its place.
With five working days, choose the pages. Read aloud the opening chapter, the last chapter and every scene marked in week 1. Then search the whole project for your repeated words and judge each instance, because some repeats are voice and should stay.
On the Free plan, Journzy checks grammar, style and typography, with lenses for repetition, rhythm, clichés and voice, plus a readability check. The lenses point at passages and name the pattern. They never write prose for you, so the new sentence is yours, or the old one stays because you judged the flag wrong. If the week runs out, stop at the marked chapters: a half-finished line pass with a clear record beats a full pass done in a fog.
Checklist:
- Read the opening chapter aloud, then the last chapter
- Read aloud every scene marked during week 1
- Search the whole project for repeated words and judge each instance
- Mend bald sentences in place, without changing facts or plot
- Note plot ideas for the next draft
- Save a snapshot at the end of the week
After 28 December: one snapshot, one reader
Save the week 4 text as a named snapshot before anyone else sees it. Comments then belong to a fixed state of the book, and they still point at real pages after you start changing it again.
Rose Tremain gives the rule for what follows, in rule 4 in part two: "Listen to the criticisms and preferences of your trusted 'first readers'." The operative word is "trusted".
On the Free plan, Journzy beta readers lets you share one named version with a reader. The reader sees only that version, not what you write after, and needs a free account with the invited email. You can revoke access at once, or it expires after 7, 30 or 90 days.
Send the reader the questions your December notes left open: a reveal that may arrive too early, an ending that follows on paper and may still feel unearned. Atwood's rabbits stay hidden from that reader, and that is why the report counts.
29 to 31 December are the spare days. Use them for overrun, or leave them empty.
Is four weeks enough to revise a novel?
Holly Lisle sets the terms plainly: "Second, set a completion date for the revision." She gives her own pace: "I can do a complete revision of a 125,000 novel in one to two weeks." And her warning points the other way: "if you're spending more than two or three months on this, consider the possibility that you might be malingering".
So four weeks is slower than Lisle's pace and well inside her warning line. The date forces decisions to happen at a pace. The order makes sure they happen in the right sequence. A date with no order produces fast line editing on a broken structure.
The honest answer is narrower than yes. Four weeks gives you a second draft. A finished book takes more drafts, a reader's report and time.
If week 2 shows that the structure is broken (an ending that does not follow, half the scenes changing nothing), stop the calendar and give structure two weeks. Weeks 3 and 4 spent on a structure you will change are wasted work. Set a new completion date and let the later weeks move with it.
Length changes the arithmetic too. A much longer book, or a draft with several braided timelines, can need the same four layers in six or eight weeks. Keep the order and stretch the weeks. Never squeeze structure into three days so that line editing can keep its full week.
The plan also needs a complete draft. If the ending is unwritten, finish it, rest, and then start week 1: the scene list needs a last scene, and the thread check needs endings to check against.
FAQ
How long should a second draft take?
In this plan, four weeks: one each for the read-through, structure, continuity and line work, with 29 to 31 December spare. Holly Lisle reports a complete revision of a 125,000-word novel in one to two weeks and warns against going past two or three months, so four weeks is slower than her pace and well under her warning. If the structure is broken, give it a second week and move the later weeks.
What do you revise first in a second draft?
Structure, after one full read-through with notes and no repairs beyond typos. The scene list from week 1 shows what each scene changes, which threads open and close, and where the novel actually starts. Continuity comes next because structural changes strand facts, and sentences come last because every earlier layer can cut or change them.
Should you fix typos during the first read-through?
Yes, and stop there. Holly Lisle corrects more in the margins while she reads (her "little mistakes" include awkward sentences), but this plan fixes only typos in week 1. A flat sentence or an awkward rhythm goes on the problem list with its chapter, because week 2 may cut that page.
Can software revise my novel for me?
Journzy will not. The author writes every word; Journzy checks the manuscript against your story bible, cites the passage or bible line behind each flag, and leaves the fix with you. The developmental diagnosis on the Author plan works the same way: it orders findings by impact, shows the evidence, and never rewrites.
Cervantes kept the readers' complaint and changed his method instead of his sentences, and a December second draft earns the same credit he asked for, "not alone for what he writes, but for what he has refrained from writing."
Keep reading
- After NaNoWriMo: fix names and timelines before sentencesThe NaNoWriMo nonprofit closed in 2025, but the 50,000-word November challenge goes on. After it, fix names, timeline and open threads before sentences.
- Checklist: audit your manuscript's continuity before you submit itAn eight-section continuity checklist—attributes, names, chronology, knowledge, relationships, places, objects and voice—with Ctrl+F tactics for any editor.